Inside Google Ads podcast: Episode 147 - Black Friday Horror Story

Listen on Apple Podcasts

What's the worst thing that could happen to your Google Ads on Black Friday?

Believe me, I have seen it all. From conversion tracking breaking to your bestsellers going out of stock early to the website team deciding that the day before Black Friday seems like the perfect time to launch a new website… Right? 

Wrong. 

Well, I recently spoke with Aaron Levy, the evangelist at Optmyzr, about a Black Friday horror story from one of my Google Ads coaching clients and it's not what you might think. 

So, tune in here for this special excerpt so that you don't make the same mistake this holiday season. 

I'm your host, Jyll Saskin Gales. I spent six years working for big brands at Google and now I work for you.

This is Inside Google Ads, Episode 147: Black Friday Horror Story.

-------

Aaron: All right, everyone. Now, we have a longtime friend of the program, someone who I've been spending a lot of time with these past couple of weeks and months around the world, which has been a great joy. I, however, have yet to see her wearing Mickey Mouse donut ears.  So, everyone, please welcome Jyll Saskin Gales and her phenomenal outfit.

Jyll: Thank you. Thank you very much.

Aaron: Jyll, what's your nightmare? Come on. Let's talk about a Q4 gone wrong. Or maybe your nightmare is the absence of something. Who knows? 

Jyll: Oh, I would say my Q4 gone wrong is a missed opportunity. I mean, sure, we've seen like losing conversion tracking, something goes wrong. I'm not talking about that kind of snafu. I'm talking about getting to Q1, looking back, and realizing you left so much money on the table. That to me is one of the scariest things that can happen.

Aaron: I love it. This, you know what this is? This is like an indie horror film. It's not what everyone expects, but it's really, really painful. Tell us a little bit about the missed opportunities report. Tell us about what you think we can do with it.

Jyll: Yes. Well, let me show you while we're talking about it. 

So, the missed opportunity report is relatively new in Google Ads. I will admit I only learned about it about a month ago. It's under the recommendations tab, which is an area of Google Ads I never go to until now, unless it's to turn off the auto apply settings. But this is a screenshot of what it looks like. And so it'll show you over the last year, week by week, how much opportunity you captured and how much opportunity you've missed. 

So what you see here, the solid blue bars, those are the conversions that this specific client got every single week. And then the blue lines show missed conversions from low budget. So essentially, these are campaigns that were performing at their target, but were limited by budget. And so I don't even have to label the bars on this chart for you to know where Black Friday and Cyber Monday and the holiday was. You can see just huge amounts of missed opportunity. 

There was so much demand in the market. And from an actual ROAS perspective, I can confirm these campaigns were kicking butt on their ROAS, way higher than usual, but the client did not increase spend through that period. And so we missed out on all those potential sales, potential repeat customers, all that good stuff. 

So, this was a horror story and you best believe this client and I have already put in a budget increase plan for this year so we don't make the same mistake again.

Aaron: I certainly hope they would. You know, actually, believe it or not, this has been a little bit of a theme in different ways. You know what's interesting? I think in Q4, Black Friday, Cyber Monday especially, your buyers are different, and so that means that your quote unquote best practices have to be different. Was this a scenario of someone just like leaving their everyday settings in? 

Jyll: Yes, it was. This is a business owner who runs her own business and also consults full-time for another business. So, this is a very busy person. We meet once every couple of months to check on things in Google Ads, but you know, I don't manage the Google Ads for her. She's not checking them every day. So, there were just so many things going on. Sales were looking so good during the holiday period, she just didn't even look at it. 

So, this year we started planning. Actually, a few months ago we already started talking about how we are going to make sure we have budget left for the holiday season? How are we going to allocate it? What's it going to look like so we don't make that mistake again?

But it's interesting what you said about best practices in the holiday season because I was actually on a coaching call earlier today with a different client and we were talking about his planned budget increases for the holidays and he said, "You know, I thought you're not supposed to change your budgets more than 10% to 20% at a time." 

And I said, "Look, that is the best practice, but for Black Friday/Cyber Monday, in e-commerce, we don't want best practice. We're not looking for steady state, reliable results. It's a big moment. We need to throw best practices out the window and make sure we capture that opportunity."

This is something I see across a lot of e-commerce accounts.

Aaron: I love that. And I mean, we know that user behavior is different and also in a lot of times like the actual user is different. I mean, so many people will be ready to buy the perfect gift for someone, but sometimes that someone is (points to himself). Not that you should buy me presents, more that self-gifting is a thing. So, you know, in Q4, you just kind of have to throw your old best practices to the wind just because everything changes. It's a weird set of holiday best practices. 

Now, of course, you kind of gave us a treat already, but do you have any other fun tips? Any other fun treats to go along with I guess the trick of absence? 

Jyll: Any other fun treats for you? Well, there are some new features in Google Ads for this holiday season that I am only just starting to test. So, I probably won't have any takeaways to share until after this holiday season, for next season. 

But AI Max for Shopping, just turned that on with one of my clients. Leveraging some of the new loyalty features in Google Ads to have, you know, different messaging and offers for only people who are part of your loyalty program. These are the things I'm excited to test. 

Oh, and of course, this seems like such a basic one, but Maximize Conversion Value bidding in Shopping campaigns. It's brand new. It's so needed, especially for the holiday season. Again, normally Target ROAS is the goal, but during this really short peak period, expecting a lot of sales, sometimes it can make sense to switch on to Maximize Conversion Value. In years past, you could only optimize for clicks. So, I'm really excited to see that bid strategy as an option. I feel like that went too far under the radar, so I had to highlight that here as well.

Aaron: You know what I really love that you're highlighting here, Jyll? Someone in the comments is going to call me a shill, but that's okay. You're highlighting the treats that engines are giving to us. These are a lot of things that, you know, I think are feedback points that we've given to Google over the years about things that we want. I've been on this little soap box for quite some time, long enough that I'm obviously getting old and dying. Okay. No, I'm not.

Jyll: You are a skeleton. 

Aaron: That’s true. This is the most comfortable thing in the world, by the way. I want to wear this for all my webinars forever. But it just goes to show that that really actionable feedback to our reps and to our folks at Google is a lot more effective than just yelling “this is stupid, I hate it.” 

But when you give them things that can be really interesting and can really help you optimize your campaigns and give it to them. I mean look, they're a business trying to make more money, but you want to make more money, too. So they have these tools so you can improve performance and as you say, and as you've shared so elegantly, not leave money on the table for someone else to go get.

Jyll: That's what I say. The house always wins, but you can win too, right? It's not a zero-sum game between you and Google all the time. So, give Google the data it needs, the budget it needs, the information it needs, so that it can give you the results that you need.

Aaron: Jyll, this has been fun. I've really had—it's been a treat spending so much time with you these past couple of weeks. I can't thank you enough for contributing to this and obviously for all you do to the industry.

Jyll: Thank you so much. I look forward to seeing you again soon. 

-------

The key takeaway from this episode today is the missed opportunity report in Google Ads. I only learned about it recently and it's a really helpful way to make sure you're not missing any opportunity during the holidays or all year round. 

Again, you can find that under your recommendations tab, a place that always collects dust in my Google Ads accounts, but not anymore.

If you like learning tips and tricks like this about the Google Ads interface, you should check out my course Inside Google Ads at learn.jyll.ca. That’s learn dot J-Y-L-L dot C-A. Because on this podcast I tell you and in my course I'll show you everything we're talking about in the Google Ads interface. Plus you get 24/7 access to JyllBot to get your burning questions answered. 

That's learn.jyll.ca.

I'm Jyll Saskin Gales and I'll see you next time inside Google Ads.

Next
Next

Inside Google Ads podcast: Episode 146 - Google Ads Failures